Aloha, this is courtesy of Gordon Cho.

During a particularly windy 4 Ball stroke event, Partner A was on the green and putting.  His Partner B's coffee cup, which was in the shared cart, blew out and struck Partner A's ball as he putted, causing it to move off line.  No one knew what to do in this circumstance and Partner B went ahead and played the ball as it lay without penalty.

Because the coffee cup belonged to his partner, should it have been considered equipment belonging to the partnership or would this be considered accidental movement of the ball on the green?

A paper cup, having blown out of the cart was not anybody's equipment, it was an outside influence, thus the answer lies . . . not in the wind, but in Rule 11.1b, Exception 2.  The stroke is cancelled and must be replayed.  When Player A putted from where his ball came to a stop, he played from a Wrong Place and should have incurred the General Penalty, or two strokes in this case.  Hopefully, his partner scored well enough it wouldn't matter for the team score.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Replacing Clubs?

Image
Q: Can I replace a damaged club? A: Generally speaking, no.  If you have started with 14 clubs you can replace a damaged club ONLY if you had nothing whatsoever to do with damaging it.  Any action (or lack of an action, such as not adequately securing your golf bag on a golf cart) that may be traced to you will eliminate your ability to replace a damaged club.  Any abuse of a club or damaging it when not using in a normal golfing manner will also make sure you can't replace it.  If you started with fewer than 14 clubs, you can add clubs to your hearts content up to the 14 club limit. (Rule 4.1a(2)) You also may NOT borrow a club from another player on the golf course. (Rule 4.1a(4)) Thank you for visiting my blog. Comment where you think the picture above was taken. Aloha, Mahalo, and see you next week!
Read more

I'll Bet This has Happened to You at some Time

As a Referee I came across three players looking for a ball in a Red Penalty Area.  They explained the shot had hit a tree within the penalty area and had bounced, but they didn't know if it was off a rock in the penalty area or something else.  They were convinced (Virtually Certain), however, that the ball was in the penalty area.  After a significant search without finding the ball, the player asked what options she had. I explained the three options (Rule 17) and she opted to take relief back on the line from the point of entry.  Off a steep downhill, side hill lie, she hit a nice draw around the tree in the penalty area and back into the fairway.  When she went forward to hit her fourth shot, she said, "Here is my first ball on the cart path.  Where do I take relief?" Sorry.  Rule 14.4 says that once the original ball has been abandoned, it may no longer be played on that hole, it is a Wrong Ball.  She had to lift it and continue on with her substituted ball.
Read more

Flagstick Laying on Green?

Last week we posed the question of what happens if you come across a green with the flagstick removed from the hole and laying on the green.  I promised a cheap dozen golf balls to the first correct response to this blog.  No takers yet. Questions to be answered -- are you entitled to leave the flagstick laying on the green while you putt? If another player wants to replace the flagstick in the hole and then putt, are you entitled to replace the flagstick on the green and then putt when it is your turn?  After all, one of the basic tenets of the game is to play the course as you find it, and you found the course with the flagstick laying on the green. Send me the correct decision and the cite, and the cheap dozen golf balls are yours.
Read more